History of Leicester Forest East services
This was a special feature presented as a story on the services's 50th birthday.
In 1962, the Ministry of Transport were looking at possible sites for a service area on the newest part of the M1 motorway. Their search didn't start well: the Ministry looked at Watford Gap and worked out where the next service area should be, and it took them to an urban area by M1 J21. Several options were assessed and none were great. But the outskirts of Leicester Forest East was chosen as the least-bad option for service area 17.
This was still early days for motorway services and for the motorway network. Service area 17 doesn't imply there were 16 services before it (there were 11, the Ministry's counting was optimistic at best). That internal working title did however prove to be catchier than the eventual name of "Leicester Forest East motorway service station"!
What Wasn't To Be
Seven names put themselves forward for the task of operating Leicester Forest East, each with their own ideas.
The Fosse Motor Company of Desford, who had no motorway experience at all but knew quite a bit about filling stations, thought they could be the ones to make this site work. Unfortunately their inexperience showed and it was an easy one to rule out. Their idea of having one long canopy crossing the motorway and bringing all the buildings together was strong and simple. They would have sat diners alongside the motorway which even then wasn't seen as ideal. They planned to lease out to a catering company the actual restaurants: one was waitress service, one was self-service and one would have been a hybrid between the two. It just didn't really gel.
Kenwell Motor Services also wanted to be the operator. It would have been their first time but they had experience in helping Fortes run Barnsdale Bar. Despite this, their plans were summarised as being extremely poor. At the time, having two separate amenity buildings was seen as unnecessarily expensive. The style wasn't really what they wanted. But most importantly, their proposals were so vague the inspectors weren't really sure what they were inspecting!
Blue Star were part-owners of Motorway Services Ltd (now Welcome Break - watch out for that name). Having let the Ministry down with their last two operations, Motorway Services Ltd didn't want to get back on the horse, so Blue Star thought they'd go it alone. This was brave for another company whose only contribution to service stations so far had been putting fuel in the pumps, but they came back with something truly modern, something that had clearly been designed by a competent architect.
There were two mirroring buildings, a grill and griddle restaurant with timber strips lining the roof. A large free-standing staircase took customers up to the entrance hall, shop and restaurant from a paved downstairs area. Toilets were downstairs and a bridge plugged into the entrance hall at each end. Outside, the building would have been covered with steel and glass. Away from all the glitz, Blue Star were the only rejected proposal to offer a thorough and effective financial proposal, which was just as important. It was a really good effort, and then the inspectors turned the page. Their proposal for a one-size-fits all restaurant and menu was "unsuitable", and really "very poor". That cost them dearly.
Blue Star did not know that their fellow co-owners felt exactly the same way, and Fortes (now part of Welcome Break - hmm) had submitted a bid too. They made use of the embankments by having one small building at bridge-level, much like Medway. It "had the hall mark of the experts". But something wasn't right: Leicester Forest East deserved something bolder, something which could live up to its long name.
If it was inspiration you needed, Top Rank had their name written all over this. They were so keen to get involved, they bid twice. "Rank A" had two different restaurants on each side of a bridge, and a kitchen in the middle. Their large expanses of tarmac outside reminded Ministers of the worst parts of Watford Gap. "Rank B" was similar but without the bridge, creating two small and difficult to operate amenity buildings. Top Rank had a habit of coming up with ideas so ambitious they could never afford to pay the Ministry back, and this time the Ministry steered well clear.
The Final Two
If none of those proposals sound like the modern-day Leicester Forest East to you, that's because there's still two more to go. One of them won the contract - and the other came very close.
Granada had just opened Toddington and were about to bid for Frankley. Even 30 years before their infamous monopoly, they believed that biggest could be best. Toddington was the biggest service station around when it opened, and another big one just a short way up the road could be exactly what they needed to squeeze the others out.
They proposed an "extravagant" building on the east/southbound side only. With an 840 seat restaurant, two 112-seat transport cafés (one for each side), a snack bar (an early Greggs effort), a lounge and a café; they meant business. On the northbound side, space was left for an eventual amenity building.
Initially they wanted an uncovered bridge to link the two sides, but they reluctantly accepted a covered walkway would be necessary: this would have led to a concourse area where the upstairs restaurant and toilets were. Downstairs was a shop, post office, more toilets and a kitchen. Their large range of facilities appeared to be subtly aimed at local pedestrians while Granada waited for motorway traffic to pick up.
The restaurant intended to set a very high standard, with a deep carpet and woodblock flooring. The less pricey cafés would have been in bright colours.
Not all their big ideas were clever. The large first-floor restaurant promised great views of the surrounding area (much like Frankley southbound), but they also proposed large trees which would have blocked the view. It was all a bit bulky. And the Ministry knew full-well an 840-seat restaurant on a brand-new motorway would close straight away due to low demand. Considering this, although they had offered the Ministry impressive financial returns, the Ministry weren't convinced Granada proposal had actually offered themselves any room to make any money - and that would be a gamble.
There were several groups responsible for choosing the winning bid, and the Department for Transport backed Granada.
Ross won design points straight away by proposing to put the petrol stations by the exit. Experience had shown that this was the way to go, but most proposals still hadn't got the message.
The idea of putting terraces - shielded slightly from the motorway - at each end of the two-storey bridge-come-amenity building was a new one, and one that scored more points. They even considered raising the entire southbound car park just so it would meet the entrance at bridge-level, but their decision to back down on that one allowed for some more sensible financial proposals.
On the bridge, there was a covered walkway on the north-facing side, and a 690-seat Captain's Table restaurant on the south-facing side, as the view to the south was better. The Motorgrill restaurant intended to be luxurious but not expensive, and again proposed a luxurious, deep carpet.
Outside were two transport cafés, which were slightly isolated and eventually ruled out.
The Minister in charge still liked bridge restaurants, and the Landscape Committee and Leicestershire County Council's architect both preferred Ross. Also impressive was its name. Frozen food retailer Ross had been intrigued by the motorway industry and wanted to get involved as it seemed like a novel way to market themselves. They were guaranteed to provide good catering as that is what they do as a business. From the start, the Ministry had wanted to invite relative newcomers into the service station industry but very few had avoided making major mistakes. And here was Ross, making the final short-list. They won the contract.
Who are Ross? They're now part of Welcome Break. Destiny!
Opening a Legend
On 15 May 1966 the services fully opened. Its five-star, fine-dining offer was an instant hit with motorway users and local residents. It was very-well furnished: with not many service stations or local 24-hour buildings in place at the time, a few weeks after opening the services were raided by criminals, who stripped the building of only its furniture.
Excitement brimmed in the architecture. A short water tower continues, to this day, to be used for marketing. After a few modifications, inside were bright colours and gleaming stainless steel. Red settees were used in the café, while the restaurant had a horseshoe counter with a kitchen in the centre. A Which? review of motorway services concluded that Leicester Forest East had the only decent restaurant on the motorway network.
At the time all new motorway services were grand, but Ross applied a finish which put Leicester Forest East well above the rest. It was proof that the tendering process can work - and what a result it was.
End Of The Honeymoon Period
With more motorway services opening in the following years, motorway dining stopped being a novelty. Trowell had just opened up the road and also promised a unique dining experience. Elsewhere, with rival operators taking away and cutting down on facilities, customers' interest in Ross's fine-dining waned and caused them to cut back on operating costs - with disastrous results.
Quality at Leicester Forest East dropped dramatically, and with new services continuing to open, it had absolutely no unique selling point. Waitress service moved towards unreliable automatic catering. Even the terrace was forced to close and the walkway was adopted by the main amenity building, bringing some life into the dead restaurant.
Ross looked at their own finances and reputation, and were not pleased with the situation they had got themselves in. To reduce the damage they renamed their motorway operation to "Motoross" and in 1969, they refused to build any more motorway services at all, until the government changed the way they are regulated.
Their protest didn't work, and Ross instead decided to join the rest, and gave their beloved service area a betting shop, ice cream stall and a separate Happy Eater restaurant. At a time when motorway services were accused of being low-brow and offering terrible food, the best Ross could offer was to be one of the same.
Another change Ross made was trialling the first motorway conference room, in 1972. In 1977 Egon Ronay rated the services as poor, but did concede that the main restaurant was "borderline acceptable". He said it was "attractively designed" but the convenience food was a let-down, especially the "hamburger which could have been made of anything".
Thrown A Lifeline
It all became too much for Ross, and in 1984 the services were sold to Hanson Trust who decided to bring back the name they had been saving for a special occasion, Welcome Break.
From the word go, Welcome Break were just a service area operator. They were one of three big ones, and they were corporate in their nature. Gone was the stylish fish restaurant and instead there was a pizza shop, ice cream kiosk, burger bar named Burger Break and a Happy Eater.
A brief flirt with Granada saw those names replaced by Burger King and Little Chef added to the services - the latter later becoming Red Hen. Practical but significant extensions saw single-storey areas expand into the car park.
Try as they might, Welcome Break couldn't hide the quirky features and ageing looks which plagued the services. For several years you couldn't leave the services without walking through the shop: this wasn't by design, but they didn't have enough space for a corridor. This was made worse by the fact that most of the facilities were upstairs, again because there wasn't a lot of room. Originally blue in colour, this scheme lasted some time, until a few corporate experiments saw it painted Coffee Primo orange and KFC red.
In December 1999, Welcome Break opened their first Days Inn motel here, by rearranging the road and parking layouts.
LFE Bites Back
Fans of Leicester Forest East - of which there were quite a few, who saw it as Leicestershire's best landmark - a credit to the county architect who approved it, were gutted in 2007 when it was announced the services would be closing.
Its suburban location had seen a lot of growth on the surrounding motorway network, and the next upgrade proposals needed most of the car park, and the building to be gone. After an uncertain period, the plans were postponed indefinitely. As political motives change it is likely that the plans to widen the M1 and upgrade J21 will come back - but whether they'll ever make it to fruition or not is another debate.
With any fears about closure being off the cards for the time being, Welcome Break have been free to run it as a major commercial asset - which is exactly what it is. And actually, despite initial criticisms, they do a very good job.
The fast food court may not be in the spirit of the Ross' 1960s dreams, but Welcome Break know how to breathe life into something which otherwise wouldn't work. Their most recent extensions, to provide Waitrose shops, mask the worst of the architecture while the best of it is still unchanged when you drive underneath. And even though the catering options aren't the same as they once might have been, they continue to welcome and excite thousands of motorists who rush up to the second floor.
Even if catering turnover is their primary concern - and as a commercial business, it should be - Welcome Break are well aware that they own an oddity, and they know how to get the most out of it. A Starbucks drive thru in the car park brings a little bit of 2016 to a service area which looks back nostalgically at 1966.
Beat that, Keele.
- The Rise and Fall of Leicester Forest East
- Leicester Forest East
- Leicester Forest East photos
- BBC News article